« Critter Crashes Into Michigan Salon, Uses Bathroom | Main | Northern Quebec's Pristine Rupert River in Trouble »

December 19, 2006

This page has been moved to http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes

If your browser doesn’t redirect you to the new location, please visit The Field Notes at its new location: www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes.

Is This Incredible Photo for Real?

Check out this photo sent in by a friend. His email was entitled, "Photographed by a Hunter in Montana" and read:
Don't know if this is real--people can do pretty amazing things with computers--but if it is, it's a pretty crazy shot.
If you know anything about this photo, let us know.
Thanks, Todd.

Image001

Comments

drake

its feet are in the snow

jose hernandez

after going to the site and checking out the entire series of 5 pictures , i believe they are real . check out the small black bird that flies in front of the confrontation .

Scott Gross

As a photographer, I know what to look for in a picture when it comes to seeing digital effects. These photo's are authentic. The biggest clue is the light. That's the first thing to look for. The angle of light and the direction of shadows, which, in this case, all line up perfectly. That is extremely difficult to accomplish when adding different elements together to make a complete picture.

G. Warren

THe "small black bird" is a magpie, which are scavengers.

Rog

I saw this happen on a Colorado elk hunt earlier this year, except it was 6 goldens hitting a coyote in an open field. They would take turns divebombing the 'yote and each time they would he would jump and try to grab at the eagles. The 'yote finally hit the tree line and got away

Joe S.

The shadows don't match, and I see none for the fox. What seems to be a shadow of the magpie is much lighter than the others.....also, if the carcass has been picked out why is there so much undisturbed snow on it.

kidd billy

i don't believe golden eagles have
the white stripe on it's wings.i think the picture might be possible but i thinks it's a hawk
enlarged a nd super imposed

it's a fake

al the infidel

You guys just like arguing, get married and you'll get over it. I photog and have doctored a few for the fun of it and you can not tell sometimes. I told the fish cop the pic with my wife and a 9# "looking" yellow perch was doctored and he still asked me repeatedly; "So how much did it weigh?" Pictures can be deceiving-period.

Jim

The picture is a fake. The eagle would have already been well over the top of the fox if not past the fox (because of momentum) in the photo when it let go AND the talons should be down or behind the eagle. The photo shows the talons in the position that it is ABOUT to grab something, not that it has just let go of something as heavy as a fox. If the fox was spun around, it is even more reason to believe the eagle would be past the fox in the photo because the eagle would drag the fox around, not push it along while picking it up. It's pretty simple, the eagle and the talons are in the wrong positions for this shot to be real.

BJH

It's fake. There are no front feet on the fox. They were cut off in the paste. Look at the dimensions. The eagle's body is bigger than the fox. The eagle doesn't even have a grip on the fox. If it did, or even if the pic was taken as the eagle let go, the fox would not be in that position.

Michael

I can not speak to whether or not the photo has been doctored. I can speak to whether the scenario is likely. It is not. First, the eagle in that picture has not hit its target yet. Why then is the fox ass over tea kettle? Even if you allow that the fox is leaping from being startled, it would leap head first. Finally, as an aside, dare I say that is not a fox? If it is, I must say I have never seen one so thick around the middle and with haunches as large as those and a fox's snout is tiny compared to what is in that photo. That is a coyote.

shane taylor

FAKE.... ITS THE MITTLE OF WINTER IN THE SNOW THE CARCAS IS MISSINGTHE MEAT IN THE RIBS DONT KNOW OF MANY PEOPLE WHO TAKE RIB MEAT OUT AND ANIMALS WOULD NOT EAT THE MEAT OUT LIKE THAT PLUS THE EAGLE IS TOO BIG AND NOT FACING THE RIGHT WAY

Bill Schooner

The photo is FAKE. Due to the talons are not in, on or into the fox. Both open and away from the body.
Eagle's eye's are down away, not looking at the fox!
Talon's, one is forward the fox's body, while the second is behind the fax?
No fox reaction. i.e.: To try to bend and bite the eagle in defense? Just hanging limp?
The Eagle is approx. 4-5' off the ground, but the fox's fore paws are in the snow?
The fox's body seems to be closer than the eagle? As in super imposed, like all the other fake photo's.
The smaller bird would have been further away from the carcass. Once the eagle came down, grabbed the fax. That bird would have been at most double the distance.
Last but not least, an Eagle would not jeopardize injury with a larger prey, than what was available.
I vote TOTAL FAKE.

Everett DeWitt

I have watched just such a fight here in Wyoming. The outcome though, was the Golden Eagle killed and ate the fox after a 30 minute fight. It happened in Febuary, 1994 in Natrona County, Wyoming

Lee B.

Well mullet,
You can come and try to hang with me anytime and well see whos real...

Dan Morris

Kinda reminds me of a goose that my mom had that would attack large dogs and peaple . The dog by the way was my saint benard . The dog could have had him for lunch but probably figured that their must have been something wrong with that goose .

Dan Morris

Kinda reminds me of a goose that my mom had that would attack large dogs and peaple . The dog by the way was my saint benard . The dog could have had him for lunch but probably figured that their must have been something wrong with that goose .

Ben

The pic looks real to me but it was not taken in Finland. The other birds are black billed magpies, which are limited to the western US, western Canada, and southern Alaska. ...Just to add a little more fuel to the fire.

Kaisa

In Finland they have a bird called a "harakka" which IS a magpie in English (for more info check out www.birdphoto.fi/lajikuvat/picpic/)

Check your facts

Are you still debating whether or not this is real? The actual info was already posted by 'hull'.

The photo and the rest of the series are real. Taken in Finland. And Dan, magpies do live in Finland.

The photographer:
http://www.tarsiger.com/person.php?tunnus=komi&lang=fin

The entire photo set:
http://www.tarsiger.com/index.php?pic_id=komi1142612071&lang=fin

Snopes link:
http://www.snopes.com/photos/animals/eaglefox.asp

CP

I think this pic. is real. First of all it is an eagle,(one of the camments was that it wasn't an eagle)its just a juvinile(the white feathers on the wings). With the comments about how the eagles talons aren't on the fox, they aren't on because the eagle has already lifted the fox in the air, but doesn't have enough lift to hold on for a longer time. I have heard and seen Golden eagles take fawns many times and considering that your average fox only weighs about 10 pounds, it would be a pushover for an eagle to take it on.

predators predator

Please take the time to copy and paste the link for all of the pics before judging this one. Then, come back and give the photographer credit for bringing us such a spectacular view into nature that we would have missed except for his talent and dedication. Otherwise I'd have to say that you can't see the forest for your colon.

Miikka

It's real for your information.
Is it so hard for you guys to believe that one can get lucky once in a life.
Stupid Yankees.

Miikka

And it was definitely taken in Finland.




Our Blogs



Syndicate