« Why You Should Practice Your Offhand Shot | Main | New York Newspaper Invading Gun Owners Privacy? »

December 13, 2006

This page has been moved to http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/gun-nut

If your browser doesn’t redirect you to the new location, please visit The Gun Nut at its new location: www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/gun-nut.

Why Darting Isn't Hunting

A recent issue of Sports Afield Magazine ran an unusual piece about elephant “hunting” in Africa, in which the pachyderms are  shot with a dart gun. This follows the current fad for darting white rhinos and posing with the doped-up beasts as they sleep off their nembutol, or whatever it is.

Ted Kerasote, who wrote the article (titled “The Green Hunt”), was enthusiastic about the practice, as it allowed you to “hunt” elephants without killing them. Well, OK, if it makes his liver quiver. The only problem I have with the whole business is that it’s not hunting. To illustrate this, let’s look at a couple of other pursuits.

The object of professional boxing is see to who can pound the stuffing out of whom. Olympic boxing, on the other hand, counts only the number of punches landed, and goes to some lengths to make sure that no one is inconvenienced by an authentic ass-whipping. That is the reason it’s followed by so many with such rapt boredom. Can anyone name an Olympic boxing champion in any weight division since Sugar Ray Leonard won gold in 1976?

And then there is bullfighting, which is not considered a sport by its fans but a form of theatre, the object of which is the demonstration of courage in the face of death. Take the death out of it and all you have is a guy in tights embarrassing both himself and a bull in a stadium full of people.

Hunting, and especially the hunting of dangerous game, is about life and death. If you try to kill an elephant there is always the chance he will kill you, and the death of one of you is what gives the enterprise its meaning.  If you yearn to stick a needle in the rump of some poor elephant, by all means do so, but don’t file the activity under “hunting.” It ain’t.


TrackBack URL for this entry:

Listed below are links to weblogs that reference Why Darting Isn't Hunting:


Steve Bodio

The whole experience is important. As Ortega said, you can't hunt without killing. I myself can't hunt without eating. I think purist catch and release fly fishing, the nearest analogy to this, is politically correct fish torture for the squeamish.

Kerasote has written some good stuff but he is way off on this issue. And I suspect African humans who actually have to live with elephants, as opposed to guides (who I am sure will have their heavy backup rifles ready to protect the delicate "hunters") and buraucrats, will become a LOT less supportive of elephants if they are not culled.


I don't know about African big game, but when I heard about David Frabman (or whatever his name is) wanted to have 'professional' hunters dart deer in Michigan (my home state), I was really angry. I was brought up as a hunter, a provider, if you will. We (my brothers and I) were taught that if you're gonna shoot something, make sure you're gonna eat it. I've got no problem shooting does, I eat it. That's what hunting is to me. Not just shooting things, but taking a life to feed yourself and maybe a family. I hope his idea never goes through, I'd go there and start "darting" the "professional" hunters partaking.

Our Blogs