« South Dakota To Join Push for National Park Elk Hunting | Main | Exclusive Interview: Ten Questions For Jim Zumbo »

April 03, 2007

This page has been moved to http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes

If your browser doesn’t redirect you to the new location, please visit The Field Notes at its new location: www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes.

Discussion Topic: Are Wild Pigs a Prize or Pestilence?

In much of the country, wild hog hunting is going . . . well, hog wild. But the animal’s growing population in some states is causing alarm among wildlife officials, who say feral pigs spread disease, ruin habitat for native wildlife, and even kill fawn deer. Two concerned states are Iowa and Pennsylvania.

From the Associated Press:

"They destroy the natural habitat that's out there," said Angi Bruce, who heads the Iowa Department of Natural Resource's southwest wildlife bureau. "It basically looks like a plow has gone through the area. . . .

"There are a lot of people who have been down to the southern states and have enjoyed hunting them there, and would like to see that in Iowa," Bruce said. "That's a huge problem."

And from Pennsylvania’s The Morning Call:

"I think we're getting close to the point where this thing is going to be an unstoppable train," said David R. Griswold, assistant director of the state Agriculture Department's bureau of animal health and diagnostic services. . . .

"Having a large population of feral swine in an area is not without trade-offs, because they compete with deer, turkeys and grouse," [he] said. "You better like hunting hogs, because you are going to be hunting fewer of Pennsylvania's other game species in that same area."

What do you think? Is this a good trade-off or a bad one? Are pigs a prize or a pestilence?

Comments

Gable Sadovsky

Both. Having grown up in S. Texas they are fun to hunt, but they tear up the roads and compete directly with deer, in college we did a deer survey which indicated they took upwards of 10% of the anual fawn crop! The midwest needs longer hunting seasons and DNR's who are run by actual biologists, trust me they dont need hogs.

They are definitely a pest. I know a farmer who had 10-20 acres of his best wheat crop destroyed by them. It was so rough he couldn't even run his combine through it. Also I live out in the country and had them up in my back yard rooting up the yard due to the dry weather. Once they get started in an area they are hard to stop.

Nate

It's hard for me to go one way or the other on this issue because I live in East Texas and that area has a large population of feral hogs that cause more harm than good. They pretty much destroy everything in their path. I will say that hunting them is very exciting, esepcially since I usually spotlight-hunt (which is legal in Texas as long as you contact the game warden and let him or her know ahead of time. Sometimes they'll even provide you with bullets to do it!), and even with such lax hunting regulations on this animal the total numbers in some areas is alarming. Some see this as a problem, and while it is, I see it as more of an opportunity.

josh

I love hunting everything but it is easy to find ham in the grocery store, not so easy to find a lot of venison or other wild game. I can do without pigs running around my neck of the woods. If I was really interested in going after hogs I would go south. They don't need to be coming north

Trevor

I live in Florida and the hogs are terrible. You can shoot one a day for a year and still have hogs on your property. They do compete with deer and turkey. Probably a good reason we dont even a healthy quail population anymore also. You dont want hogs on your property. They eat everything you plant for deer, turkey and quail. Feeders are eventually taken over by hogs and they are a pest. Shoot every hog you see and dont hesitate to wound more. Thats the way we do it!!

Russell

Here in north east Texas, we have areas over run with them, and a short distance away none at all. I think a plentiful food supply is the key. While there's ample proof they are distructive, and compete with other wildlife, I love having two big animals as tasty as hogs and deer to hunt in the same place. It is common knowledge we have less deer because of them, but there's still deer - another testament to the deer's adaptabillity- I think other factors are at work when we look at quail and turkey. Land use being the biggest.

SHOOT2TH1LL

I wish more people would view them as pests. Now that the state of California has started to realize that people actually like to hunt them tag prices have skyrocketed. I love hunting them, i just hate paying beurocrats to hunt for them

Larry

This is an interesting post. We don't have hogs in my state. But the articles I've read and shows I've seen made me think it might be nice to have that opportunity here. I didn't know they were so destructive. I guess I'd be better off traveling to hunt hogs.

the pawesome

Pennsylvania has enough enough problems with its deer management program without having wild pigs destroying habitat and killing fawns. Besides, who needs to import another big game species to hunt when we've already got one of the best black bear populations in the U.S. In fact we have so many they are actually starting to become a pretty big nuisance in some areas. You guys can keep your pigs.

BP

Just in case people don't know, Pennsylvania already has wild boars roaming a few parts of the state, they escaped from those high fence "hunting" (more like shooting) preserves. The state has asked hunters to shoot any hogs they might see out in the woods, but ill tell u what there is no way to get rid of them all because they breed like rabbits and will continue to escape from preserves so really all we can do is take advantage of another game species which actually is kinda nice because they aren't regulated so u can shoot them as much as u want and as many, plus i would love to get into running catch dogs like they do in the sourth, so i say i hope they continue to breed in the state of PA, the more game species the better

Matt Mallery

Feral pigs are fun to hunt and provide tasty meet. However, they are a non-native species and a burden on the ecosystem. We should continue to hunt them and enjoy it while it lasts, but the goal should be to eliminate them. However, I do think this should apply to all non-native species. Stocking non-native fish into streams and lakes merely for recreational purposes has had just as much, if not more, of an impact on ecosystems. It's hypocritical to allow our liscense fees to support this but complain about feral pigs. Also, Texas is horrible about allowing non-native species into it's state. Axis deer, fallow deer, mouflan sheep. All to make a buck. These animals should stay on their own continents. This goes for New Mexico also, which has a population or Oryx (gemsbok). No exotics should ever be imported period.

Gable Sadovsky

Matt,
I agree with you that the introduction of non-native species without a doubt causes problems both in the introduction of additional parasites, and so often in game species--those new commers directly compete against native animals for food and other natural resources. But,without the importation of some species (for example the Black-Buck antelope to Texas) they would likely be on the endangered species list. Black-Bucks (native to India) are unable to sustain a breedable population, and in fact there are more of these animals in Texas than on their native soil. Now your right that the importation of many species is motivated by economic gain, but how else do you propose to help save such species. Once again I agree with you that importation of non-native species often times brings about problems, but to say it should be prohibited is not prudent.

Dan

It is amazing they are spreading so fast NOW... we've been here with domesticated pigs for how long? Shoot, women would let their pigs loose in the streets of NYC in the early 19th century until that practice was outlawed. It amazes me that more wild populations had not been established sooner and in more places!

Dan

jerry collinsworth

i think it just gives us cause to go and hunt these critters just as we would any other type of game , their great as table fare and are exciting to hunt, so if anybody knows where a guy from the northcoast of lake erie can hunt some pigs in the southern part of ohio , please let me know, thanks

Dorance Fitzsimonds

The more pigs shot the better. They are a problem in many areas of the South & Southwest. If you see pigs or sign of thier rooting ask the farmer or rancher if you can hunt them, he will most likely be happy to have you shoot them. Pigs are not owned by the state like deer and can be legally shot all year round in most states. But before you hunt them check by phone with the state authorities to make sure. Shoot straight. They make GREAT BBQ.

Smith Dewlen

Man, what a quandry.

I feel they are both a prize and a pestilence. No, I am not running for President of the USA.

I prize them for the skill required to take these animals. I truly fnjoy the wild pork far better than the stuff from the grocery.

Yes. They do reek havoc on the habitat and compete with other game animals and will certainly devour the turkey/quail/pheasant nest, dig out a cottontail den.

With their ability to reproduce, there is little chance of their demise as a species.

We just need more hunters to realize this and landowners willing to allow hunting for them without high trespass pass fees.

Caution must be taken when preparing the meat to keep disease from intering the human body. Also I suggest wearing strong Nitrile gloves when processing the animal.

Mike Christian

I live in Iowa and we're beginning to hear about feral hogs in our state, but I can't get the DNR to let out detailed info about where to find the land owners to see about hunting them. You would think they would like to clean our state of them as soon as possible but it looks like they're dragging their feet about it.

BIRDdwn

to some of the hunters who think pigs are great because they are free done fool yourself. this is america and capitalist. here in california tag prices are skyrocketing. as soon as the gov't realizes you'll pay for something they put their finger right smack dap in the center of your pocket

Mark Darland

On the property where I hunt one of the standing rules is that pigs are shot on sight and then usually cooked over an open flame. They make a great lunch/dinner/snack. Our rules and regs say that if you are hunting pigs on public land you must have a current hunting license and tags for whatever season it is (ie. must have your deer tags if it's deer season). My guess would be that a tag for pigs isn't far away here in Oklahoma. Happy hunting and keep it safe!

Here in Michigan, all swine fall under Federal protection according to the DNR, and when I asked about "feral"-or actual wild-hogs doing damage to wildstock or one's property I received a sarcastic answer stating that shooting any type of pig "could cost you an arm and leg in fines and possible federal procecution if caught with the animal" Now I asked why they are protected if they threaten local game and tear up property? I am waiting for a response from my follow-up question which I e-mailed them over a year ago...For this reason,I don't totally support nor trust the DNR on this issue, for they can be self serving for whatever reason that's not in the best interest of the local game.

ggg223

Like the other respondents from Texas, I find them to be both. Fun to hunt and good to eat(when you kill the right type and prepare it correctly)but extremely destructive. One thing I can tell you for sure, they ain't goin away unless there is a unified agressive effort on the part of sportsmen, wildlife mgrs, state officials etc.

vics


hunting wild boar is a sport which much to be respected as any other blood sport .
from few comments its not truly to be sportsman like but rather trigger happy slaughter squad intentions .
change in hog population cud be better than the ever growing human population .

dug verstraete

Want info on hunting hogs. Equipment, close to Ia, cost, websites,eyc.

RJM

They breed like rats. Their wallows, rooting and rubs ruin the woods. They kill fawns like a bear, they eat upland game's eggs and they do more damage to the terrain than ATV's after a week of rain. Any Eastern Deer Rifle will do the job in taking one down, but only a steady attack of Napalm would eliminate them from an area.
I am glad that we don't have many in the Northeast (except for a herd somewhere in New Hampshire. I don't think hunting them in the South can be too much fun (heat, humidity and mosquitos!)

Bubba

RJM

Think they are not in your state? Guess again! The only state that may not have feral hogs is Alaska. They have the Russian breeding and can survive the cold winters. Don't be surprised if they show up there too!

Bubba




Our Blogs



Syndicate