« Cheney Shooting Update: Victim suffers minor attack; heat intensifies on VP | Main | Maryland Bruin Bill: Proposed legislation would outlaw bear hunting »

February 16, 2006

This page has been moved to http://www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes

If your browser doesn’t redirect you to the new location, please visit The Field Notes at its new location: www.fieldandstream.com/blogs/field-notes.

Follow Up Editorial: Vice President Cheney Accepts Blame for Accidental Shooting

Doug Pike is a Field & Stream contributing editor who covers the outdoors for the Houston Cheney_hunt_lg1Chronicle. He wrote an article for us on Monday about reports of a so-called "Texas Protocol"  suggesting that bird hunters in Texas follow different gun safety rules than bird hunters anywhere else. Here's what he has to say about the Vice President's appearance on Fox News yesterday evening.

In a Wednesday interview with Fox News' Brit Hume, Vice President Dick Cheney shouldered full responsibility for his South Texas hunting accident.

"I'm the guy who pulled the trigger," the vice president said. "That's the bottom line."

In the interview, Cheney laid out details of the Saturday-afternoon incident in which he shot 78-year-old Harry Whittington during a quail hunt.

"The image of him falling is something I'll never be able to get out of my mind," Cheney said.

Cheney drank a beer with lunch. It's good that he admitted to it, but the consumption took place hours before the shooting. It's a nonissue, much as this whole incident should be soon. (For the record: Alcohol was a factor in only two of the 101 hunting accidents reported in Texas during the past three years.)

This accident was caused by poor judgment, and Cheney was right to come forward and say so. He called Saturday "one of the worst days of my life," as it would be for any hunter thrust into the same gut-wrenching position.

It's important to note that early reports putting Whittington at fault were just plain wrong. The ultimate responsibility for an accidental shooting lies with the person who fires the gun, as the vice president finally pointed out.

Compared to other sports, hunting is a safe activity. According to statistics from various agencies that were compiled by the National Shooting Sports Foundation (click here to read their report), in 2002 there were 47 hunting-related accidents per 100,000 hunters. You’re less likely to be injured while hunting than while playing golf (139 per 100,000 golfers), roller-skating (396 per 100,000), or playing softball (926 per 100,000).

Doctors in Corpus Christi say the Austin attorney is on the mend and expected to make a full recovery. His health could change, they say, but more because he's 78 than because he was hit in the face and chest by a barrage of No. 7 1/2 pellets from Cheney's 28-gauge shotgun.

--Doug Pike

Still think the VP's mistake will do significant damage to the public's perception of hunters? Let us know by taking the latest F&S poll on the home page (it's near the bottom left of the page).

Now that you've all heard more of the story from the mouth of the man himself, has anybody changed their opinion of situation? We still want your comments, and may still publish them in our May 2006 issue of the magazine.

Click here to read previously submitted comments on this topic

Comments

It. points up the fact that you can't be to careful when handling a gun.It certainly is hunters worst nightmare.I know how I'd feel even if it weren't even a particular friend.

It. points up the fact that you can't be to careful when handling a gun.It certainly is hunters worst nightmare.I know how I'd feel even if it weren't even a particular friend.

In his confessional interview, Vice President Cheney attempted to excuse his failure to immediately go to the media by stating that the story was complicated and not something the press corps is accustomed to reporting. Wrong. Hunting is straightforward. We take to the fields and forests with guns and try to kill things. The sport has been romanticized and ritualized, but at bottom it's a simple pursuit. The rules are simple, too. "Don't fire until you're aware of what may be hit" is not ambiguous. So long as we hunters claim that hunting is beyond the understanding of all who were not raised in the tradition, we will continue to be perceived as outsiders.

This was a terrible accident and that is all. I find it disturbing that Field & Stream doesn't recognize why this story has had such legs. Simple, it gives the media and the Liberals a chance to bash hunting, guns and a conservative all in the same breath. Why are you playing along?

In 1980, Larry Hagman of JR Ewing fame was asked by a Playboy interviewer why he sued the National Enquirer over allegations that he got drunk on the Dallas set and cursed at cast members and crew. After all, consider the source. Hagman responded that people won't remember who the source was. Suppose some executives were considering a new movie or TV series. One suggests casting Larry Hagman and another says "Gee, I don't know where I heard it but I heard Hagman is a real jerk - gets drunk on sets and clashes with everyone. Let's go with somebody else". He'd never even get a chance to defend himself.

In their haste to defend him, Dick Cheney's gun/hunting allies may have done considerable damage to the sport of hunting. How? By dismissing the incident as "a common accident in hunting".

I cringed when I heard that - multiple times. The last thing that sport hunting needs is for its own members to convey the message to non-hunters that it's common for a hunter to shoot another hunter by accident. It's a very short step from "hunters frequently shoot other hunters by accident" to the notion that hunters frequently shoot bystanders - and sending the message that campers, hikers, mountain bikers, and anglers take their lives in their hands if they recreate on national forest or BLM land during hunting season. You won't have to wonder why such people might oppose sport hunting close to cities, parks, and resorts - and support more restrictions on hunting on public lands.

I see another potential problem. How do sport hunters attract more non-hunters (especially kids) into the sport if it's viewed as dangerous? Imagine some kid asking his non-hunting parents for permission to hunt with a friend (and parents). If you're a parent and you hear that it's common for hunters to shoot each other by accident, would you let your kid join a hunt? I think not - remember what happened to Cheney's friend. Or more insidiously, some parent says "Gee, I don't know where I heard it but I could swear somebody said that hunters frequently shoot each other. No, Johnny can't go hunting; he should take up soccer."

The sport of hunting is in enough trouble with so many kids taking up computer games instead of outdoor sports and so much less outdoor contact among adults. We don't need to give ammunition to PETA types by telling the public that reckless hunters shooting companions is a common occurance.

IF THIS HAD BEEN ME PULLING THE TRIGGER DO YOU THINK THE NEWS PEOPLE WOULD HAVE HAD SO MUCH TIME FOR IT?HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OF ME??THE NEWS PEOPLE HAVEN'T EITHER.IT IS JUST A CHANCE TO BASH OUR SPORT AND FUEL THE ANTI GUNNERS.I HAVE HUNTED EVERYTHING I COULD AFFORD FOR 60 YRS AND HAVE NEVER BEEN SHOT OR SHOT ANYONE ELSE,ALTHO SOME TEMPED ME.

IF THIS HAD BEEN ME PULLING THE TRIGGER DO YOU THINK THE NEWS PEOPLE WOULD HAVE HAD SO MUCH TIME FOR IT?HAVE YOU EVER HEARD OF ME??THE NEWS PEOPLE HAVEN'T EITHER.IT IS JUST A CHANCE TO BASH OUR SPORT AND FUEL THE ANTI GUNNERS.I HAVE HUNTED EVERYTHING I COULD AFFORD FOR 60 YRS AND HAVE NEVER BEEN SHOT OR SHOT ANYONE ELSE,ALTHO SOME TEMPED ME.

I cannot beleive the story told by MR. Cheney. In wisconsin, we get fined for hunting with out a license. We don't get the opportunity to go in and purchase one after the fact! We must report a hunting accident immediatly to the DNR. Anyone that has taken hunter safety or has been in the military has been trained to identify the target before pulling the trigger. This man has a college education, has been nvolved with the public for most of his life and knows what to do to make it right or cover it up. I find his explanation as faulty as his reason for going into Iraq. We are held accountable as sportsmen, and rifle owners. It is sad we have this type of person in power in washington DC or any other important position in this country.

To accept the responsibility for the accidental shooting was the least the Mr. Cheney could do. After all he had violated most protocols of hunting. I understand that he has many years of hunting experience but has never having taken a Hunter Safety Course.
The basic rule of hunter safety is
knowing what is in the line of fire. Secondly shooting down, the victim was in a depression and the VP was on high ground. What was he shooting at a "sitting grouse"?

My father told me long ago, when hunting birds in a party make sure the muzzle is pointed higer than your own shoulder. Had the VP done that, he would not have shot a fellow hunter.

In my years of hunting (about 45), I personally know of about six of these accidents! We have strict rules about position and field of vision. I have left clubs that did not have strict rules in the field. In theory, this should not have happened.

It takes two to Tango. While I agree the shooter has the last responsiblility, all other hunt participants share the blame. When a bird is down, all hunters MUST stay put and keep the muzzle of their firearm pointed in a safe direction, until the bird is recovered or declared lost. Re-assume the hunting formation and continue the hunt.

Until all are ready to hunt there is no movement.

I read somewhere a question. Would Mr. Chaney learn something if he took a hunter safety course? I must honestly say, Yes." I have taken the course on three occassions and am a hunter safety instructor. If I take or give the course and I fail to glean something from the experience. I have failed myself and all hunters. There is always a tid-bit of info I had not considered or not kept in my mind. Smooting glasses are a must. One friend shot at a rabbit into the wind. Normal, so what? In this case a piece of burning powder was blown back int his eye. Something I had not considered. It is now a part of every course I teach and part of every conversation of length on hunting. It just may save someone from losing their sight.

It is a good idea for all involved in a hunting accident to take a Hunter Education Safety. Course. Come to think of it, it would be best if we all took a refresher course, before we are involved in an accident.

Sometimes bad things happen to good people. Safety is always a first priority, and this type of thing should never happen, but we are all human. I respect the VP for taking the responsibilty, but don't blame him for his mistake. We all make them.

Basic Hunter Ed 101:
Always make sure of your line of fire.

I am a hunter education instructor in Texas and a lifelong quail hunter. I am 51. I have never heard that a hunter is responsible for announcing that he is "back in Line". It is the nature of quail hunting, due to variances in the brush or terrain, that the line will waiver. It is for this reason that quail hunters are normally extra carefull to know where their hunting partners are and especially for the shooter to always not shoot until they are sure of the target and the background. Almost all upland bird hunters wear hunter orange. Was Cheney and his party?
My 13 year old son and I were on a quail hunt that very weekend. Two or three times he said; "I didn't shoot because you or Walt or the dogs were in the way." Cheney could benefit from a hunter ed class.
The excuse that the sun was in his eyes doesn't wash with carefull hunters...if you can't see, don't shoot.
Will this incident hurt the public perception of hunting? Of course. Why didn't Cheney get a ticket? Is the public to assume that a near mortal wounding with a gun doesn't even warrant a ticket?
Typical reckless Cheney behavior.

the way i see it as field and stream reported there are accidents in every sport, being an avid hunter, fisherman nascar and fopotball fanatic i have seen some of the worst, i saw sterling sharpe of GB packers break his neck i watch as micheal vick got a broken leg, i saw Dale Eranhardt Sr, deadly crash (God Bless RIP) i saw scott wimmer's car go head over heels at the 05 daytona, there are accidents in every sport but once a gun is involved the public blows it out of proportion, and with a man of VP Cheneys statue of corse this will havea negative effect on hunting, it shouldn't.....but it will. and cheney did get a warning ticket because thats what the state was doing at the time because he didnt have a stamp or something it was a warning just like all the other citizens got and he also sent the money in for the stamp that he was unaware he needed, he realized yes i made a mistake he publicly admitted it, dont end of story move on

You've got to be kidding!! The quail were hand raised and had their wings clipped!! That is horrible. What kind of sick sport is that? I'm sure you can tell that I'm not pro-hunting but that type of hunting sounds very unfair. It sounds like something Jeffrey Dahmer would have done in his early years. I wouldn't want to know a person that could shoot a hand raised bird with clipped wings.

Mr. Cheney made a mistake something that we all do. I am sure that the non-hunting public and the avid anti-hunters will make a big deal about this. That is to be expected, but there is no reason to hold the vice presedent to any higher a standard then any other human being when he is not at work. None of us are perfect. This should just reenforce gun safty in the minds of all of us that do hunt.

The Cheney incident:
The little walkie talkies that we carry to stay in touch with our hunting partners could have saved our VP alot of grief. If everyone had them and Cheney's buddy let everyone know that he was rejoining the group could have saved himself a trip to the hospital and the VP all the publicity. Of course, hindsight is always 20/20 and it was still the fault of the shooter.




Our Blogs



Syndicate